Facebook Rolls Out Check In And Expect More Privacy Criticisms

Matty Craig
I like how it makes TC load 50% slower.
157 March 1 at 9:12

Jeff Morrison · That guy at Facebook
It shouldn't; It loads in an asynchronous ifre...
98 March 1 at 9:31

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
Loads fine for me.
13 March 1 at 9:38

Avetis Zakharyan · State Engineering University of Armenia
true indeed it can't make TC load slower, except if your internet connection is bad
17 March 1 at 9:44
50 more

Donald Turnbull · Top Commenter
Facebook is starting to creep me out.
132 March 1 at 9:11

Creative Design Development Aruba
The new era is controlled by Big Brother Zucherberg.. I don't mind.. will be chaning how I communicate is all... :P
12 March 1 at 10:28

David Reeves · Web Development Manager at Superior International Industries
you are just starting to get creeped out?
17 March 1 at 10:30

Richard Johnson · Clemson
Starting?
9 March 1 at 10:38
18 more

Michael Arrington · Top Commenter · Founder at TechCrunch · 100,822 subscribers
My comment is special.
94 March 1 at 9:29

Zachary Allia · Top Commenter · Professional Cat Photographer at 64 pixels
it never shows the first comment
2 March 1 at 9:30

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
Yes Michael,

You are "special".
8 March 1 at 9:39

Nallai Wickreman · Top Commenter
Do I need to wear AOL cap to post this comment ? Testing FB comments
7 March 1 at 9:42
46 more

Mari Smith
Absolutely brilliant. Ge changer. How awesome that your can also choose to comment as yourself or any Page you administer. I look forward to when this level of comment integration with threading (plus voting up and down and credibility score!) gets added to our Facebook Pages too! :)
62 March 1 at 4:25pm

Mari Smith · Top Commenter · Passionate Social Media Leader! at Mari Smith · 53,527 subscribers
LOVE this integration! I live on Facebook anyway, so it's awesome to add more engagement to external sites via my Page.
8 March 1 at 4:28pm

Christian Karasiewicz · Johnson and Wales University
Agreed. Wonder how this will affect Disqus.
4 March 1 at 4:28pm

Chris Wilkinson
But we can't comment as our business page on personal pages...only other pages that we LIKE or administer. Otherwise, I love it.
3 March 1 at 4:33pm
47 more

Andreas Pizsa · Co-Founder & CEO at Extra+
I like that maybe the quality of comments will increase if people post with their real nes.
53 March 1 at 9:58

Thom Fountain · Help Desk/BITS at UW-Eau Claire Learning & Technology Services
That's definitely a plus.
2 March 1 at 11:47

Pluxia Mina · Ho Chi Minh City, Vietn
Or they won't comment anymore.
14 March 1 at 5:44pm
xmsrlong (signed in using Yahoo)
Its a move to idiocracy and narcissism. I mean, look at your avatar.
1 March 1 at 6:46pm
9 more

Erick Schonfeld · Top Commenter · Editor at TechCrunch · 32,633 subscribers
I really hope Facebook comments fixes the troll problem.
48 March 1 at 9:10

MG Siegler · Top Commenter · General Partner at CrunchFund · 54,722 subscribers
non-anonymous trolls exist too though :)
27 March 1 at 9:20

Robin Wauters · Top Commenter · Writer at TechCrunch · 1,444 subscribers
Ditto.
4 March 1 at 9:31

Corey Snyder · Columbus, Ohio
Fo sho!
· March 1 at 9:54
40 more

Gerald Neves
I hate that you have to unclick the "post to facebook" square underneath the comment box...Opt out not opt in....Ridiculous...
40 March 1 at 9:04

Dani Klein · erican Express
it's on purpose. they want more content on facebook.
4 March 1 at 9:19

Dien Moore · Top Commenter
Agreed, Fair annoying
· March 1 at 9:32

Javier Alcivar · Top Commenter · Guayaquil, Ecuador
At least this is the end of 90% of the trolls.
2 March 1 at 9:32
14 more

Seth Weintraub · NYU
This is the worst possible thing that could have ever happened.
29 March 1 at 9:06

Todd Jared Stearn · BU
This.
2 March 1 at 10:12

Michael York
Probably not.
4 March 1 at 12:22pm

Ben Ford · Washington State University
Most definitely. A drunk driver leaving you a paraplegic is nothing compared to facebook rolling out a new comment engine.
32 March 1 at 1:29pm
5 more

Tattoo
This looks very promising.
23 March 4 at 10:26

Marion Rehberg · Gymnasium im Loekp Marl
Eine Frau ohne Tattoos ist wie ein Auto ohne Alus:-)
· March 4 at 11:04

Moumita Basak · Calcutta Airport English High School
Its a anger 2 xprs! N attitude 2 b wt
· March 4 at 11:26

Romy Macasieb · Washington, District of Columbia
I love lp.
22 March 1 at 9:07

Julien Denoncin · Saint-Pierre, Reunion
test
· March 1 at 9:59

David Prater · CEO at FyfthNet
I second that test.
· March 1 at 10:23

David Salazar
tester
· March 1 at 10:58
28 more

Pedr Keyani · Top Commenter · Stanford · 8,618 subscribers
Sweet!
17 March 1 at 1:06pm

Chad Little · Red Lion Area Senior High School
This would make more sense as a comment on the question rather than a standalone answer.
1 March 1 at 1:15pm

Will Portnoy · Duke
Dude!
· March 1 at 1:21pm

Thomas A. Moore · Works at Hulu
Oh Pedr, did you really have to be first?
· March 1 at 3:21pm
1 more

Mayank Agarwal · Top Commenter
This is interesting... Back ward comment syncing is awesome and could be a ge changer...
15 March 1 at 9:16

Gaurab Paul · IIT Kharagpur
agree wid u mayank ... we can look forward to a much more seless interactive online experience .
4 March 1 at 9:28

Malika N Vishnu Patel
@Mayank- rolled out full fledged or still under trial/test mode?? How can i have it on my blog at http://www.bizkingdom.com/blog/
· March 1 at 9:55

Mayank Agarwal · Top Commenter
Yeah it is rolled out fully...may add a few 3rd party partners with time (google ? twitter?), Yahoo already there... It is a kind of upgrade to the earlier FB comments social plugin... Check out how to integrate here - http://developers.facebook.com/blog/post/472
· March 1 at 10:04
6 more

Dave Kerpen · CEO at Likeable Media
Like this comment if you agree this is another gechanger. Facebook #FTW!
14 March 1 at 5:12pm

Aaron Lee Wei-Ren · Chief Geek at Ask Aaron Lee · 171 subscribers
Love it!!
· March 1 at 5:19pm

Ask Aaron Lee
YES YESS I love it tooo! haha
· March 1 at 5:19pm

Brian Murray · Buzz Build Manager at Likeable Media
Wow! This is azing!
2 March 1 at 5:29pm
5 more

Sharon Seymour · Columbia University, Teachers College
Totally Sucks. Go back to Disqus.

It's slow and buggy and I don't want to post using Facebook.
13 March 1 at 9:23

Dav Yaginuma · Top Commenter
I liked Disqus. This doesn't seem worth it to me.
12 March 1 at 9:30

Raju PP · 137 subscribers
Why the hell the comment box isn't open by default? I had to click "Add a comment" every time?
11 March 1 at 9:18

Binoy Xavier Joy · Top Commenter · Tech Blogger at Compixels
To prevent sp bot attacks?
3 March 1 at 9:34

Raju PP · 137 subscribers
well, sp bots are much more sophisticated now!
· March 1 at 9:36

Farhod 'Rockwell' Shahrezay · Top Commenter · Irvine, California
maybe it will make people think twice before leaving stupid comments... Nope. That will never happen :(
3 March 1 at 9:44
12 more
f.account21 (signed in using Yahoo)
This is the only comment I'm going to write - switch back to Disqus. This was an incredibly stupid decision. P.S. I made this account solely to comment on this idiotic decision. Not all of us use Big Blue, and there are others who don't want to link their personal Facebook account with pubic activity. Nice job TC - this decision is about as smart as Gawkers new website design.
9 March 1 at 12:09pm

Carlos Andrade Jr · Owner at Virtualpetlist
Well, haters be gone because Facebook is more popula than Disqus.
· March 2 at 2:12

Andrew Warner
I wonder if sites that use Facebook's commenting system will lose their users' comments if they remove the FB system? With disqus we get to keep our comments.
9 March 1 at 11:26

Brad Mills · Top Commenter · Director at The Legend of the Psychotic Forest Ranger
good question...
· March 1 at 12:13pm

Melvin R · CSU Sacrento
This was my first thought/question as well.
· March 1 at 12:51pm
12 more

Zach Ritter · The University of Texas at Austin · 271 subscribers
Testing...
7 March 1 at 9:52

Zach Ritter · The University of Texas at Austin · 271 subscribers
Commenting from Facebook.
1 March 1 at 9:54

Zach Ritter · The University of Texas at Austin · 271 subscribers
Commenting from TechCrunch.
1 March 1 at 9:57

Chris Harris
Testing new FB commenting feature. Replying to a test comment from TC.
· March 4 at 9:00pm

barish Gupta · McKinsey & Company
There is value in de-anonymizing conversation on internet. The conversations will have more depth if there is a real person linked to it. I like it.
6 March 1 at 9:52

Steve Dondley · Top Commenter · University of Massachusetts herst
You think it will result in more depth? I'm not so sure. People will hold back and be less willing to say something risky. You will probably end up with a lot of upbeat happy talk. Who wants that?
6 March 1 at 12:53pm

Joshua McShane
It's true that there's a tradeoff: anonymity and accountability each have their pros and cons. I think that in this case, though, accountability will actually make TechCrunch comments useful. We'll see.
· March 1 at 1:41pm

Fernando Olivares
me
· March 1 at 1:49pm
3 more

Sada Kshirsagar · University of Pune
FB is building a nice fenced garden where Google, Twitter cant play.
6 March 1 at 9:32

Sada Kshirsagar · University of Pune
I wonder what the SEO implications are for this kind of commenting
1 March 1 at 9:33

Matt Mullenweg · San Francisco, California
Since it doesn't sync back into WordPress, and is only a JS include, you lose the SEO benefits of having comment content on your pages.
11 March 1 at 10:03

Fran Larkin · Platform Product Marketing at Facebook · 132 subscribers
There is an API so website owners can access the comments left by their users. http://developers.facebook.com/docs/reference/fql/comment/
2 March 1 at 10:21

Jason L. Baptiste · CEO at Onswipe
Neat. How will it plug into existing CMS systems?
6 March 1 at 9:04

Jon Steinberg · President at BuzzFeed · 2,719 subscribers
We're running it as a separate unit on BuzzFeed
3 March 1 at 9:08

Drekken Augustus Pownz · Top Commenter · Owner/Partner at Pownz eSports
very interesting
· March 1 at 9:31

Brian Breslin · CEO at Infinimedia, Inc.
how does this affect Disqus?
1 March 1 at 10:04
8 more

MicroArts Creative Agency
Facebook Pages can now leave comments on blog posts using the new Facebook comments system (as evidenced by this comment).
5 March 1 at 9:24

MicroArts Creative Agency
And then comments in reply are displayed both on the Facebook Page that left the comment and on the page where the original comment was made.
· March 1 at 9:39

Li Berry · Top Commenter · Works at Youtube.com/LiBerryTea
It's not actually letting me on my page o_O:
www.facebook.com/TheYoutube
· March 1 at 9:52

Colleen Robledo Greene · Systems Librarian at California State University, Fullerton
Yeah, but, it this isn't very useful. What would be useful to Page Admins, is if this commenting app would publish ALL comments to the associated FB Page. I have FB Pages for several blogs that I manage. I'd want ALL comments posting through the FB commenting tool to appear on both my blog AND my associated FB Page.
2 March 1 at 10:07
11 more

Dien Uztest-Deux · Paris, France
I like turtles.
45 March 1 at 9:27

Steve Benner · Lancaster, Lancashire
Yup. Turtles are cool.
4 March 1 at 10:00

Olivier Lendresse
Best. Animal. Ever.
4 March 1 at 10:40

Renate Rena Nuss · Broker / Marketing Associate at Coldwell Banker Real Estate Corporation
delicious
1 March 1 at 11:00
50 more

Grizzly Brears · The Internet'te Marketing
Great - now it only takes 20 seconds to load a TC page...
5 1 Mart, 09:15

Grizzly Brears · The Internet'te Marketing
I wonder if the techie crowd would get upset if a marketer started playing with FB and had a bunch of friends show up and hit the *like* button on everything they were peddlin'... in the techchrunch comments...
9 1 Mart, 09:34

Aleksey Korzun · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
This obviously happened before Facebook comments.
· 1 Mart, 10:10
Diğer 5

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
Need lazy loads so we don't have to click "274 more".
5 1 Mart, 09:58

Jeff Schnitzer · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Stealthy Startup'ta Founder
I have used Facebook Comments to comment on a blog article about Facebook Comments. Just *try* to outmeta me.
5 1 Mart, 12:37

Nikolai Sander
http://techcrunch.com/2011/03/08/crowley-unsubscrib/
· 8 Mart, 12:45

Sean Percival · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Science'de Entrepreneur In Residence
FIRST (fb comment).
5 1 Mart, 10:56

Rona Shuman
Cool.
· 1 Mart, 11:13

Greg Voakes · Victoria, British Columbia
Sup Sean :D
· 1 Mart, 11:55

Patrick Srail · MySpace
That's spelled "frist". Wonder how much time TC spent evaluating this platform. Looks interesting.
· 2 Mart, 00:39
Diğer 3

Christophe Rel · Acti - agence web interactive'de Community Manager
Great news!
5 1 Mart, 09:18

Cyril Lopez
C'est bon contre le troll
Par contre ça force à avoir Facebook (si si j'en voit au fond qui n'ont pas de compte).
· 1 Mart, 10:05

Raphaël Hunold · M6 Web'de Community Manager
C'est quand même assez énorme. On va en voir fleurir un peu partout. Par contre au niveau stats je suis un peu perplexe...Ce qui fait surtout peur, c'est le fait que FB garde tout pour lui et que ces commentaires ne puissent pas être synchroniser avec la bdd de site tiers...
· 3 Mart, 09:19
Diğer 2

Karyn L. Fiebich · Oregon
I dig this, it's breaking the barrier of plugging content on social channels. It allows the user to publish to Facebook, or not, (way better feature than Facebook making the decision for the user, like the new system with the "like" button in websites).

This feature creates a seless integration between the brands website content and their advocates social channels. Loyalty is a function that most companies want to establish with their brand advocates participation, this makes those people who are valuing their brand (& content) visible to both the company and that persons network, creating a broader word of mouth value for the company.

A good first version, this feature still has a ways to go, as the article illustrates.
4 1 Mart, 10:39

Karyn L. Fiebich · Oregon
Are you going to back up your opinion with an intelligent reason?
1 2 Mart, 06:30

King Brick
I love Disqus, and I use it for loads of blogs. I hate Facebook and use it to keep in touch with friends and fily. Don't really want to go merging those things. Loose loose IMO...
4 1 Mart, 09:10

Frank Jes · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
Don't like... can't post images... can't see new messages pop up in real time...
4 1 Mart, 09:11

Frank Jes · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
I can't even edit my post? How is this comparable?
4 1 Mart, 09:12

Frank Jes · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
Also, when scrolling down to see more comments, they are often repeate comments. The se ones over and over again.
3 1 Mart, 09:15

Frank Jes · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
I can like my own comment... Awesome...
8 1 Mart, 09:20
Diğer 8

Jaakko Kuivalainen · Sanoma News'te Head of Online Performance Unit
This a test, not a genuine comment.
4 1 Mart, 09:34

Ari Wallach · Synthesis Corporation'da CEO & Founder
I second that test.
2 1 Mart, 10:48

Jay Stakelon · Fullscreen'de VP Product
I, too, support this test.
2 1 Mart, 11:12

Teo Lisitza
Test guy supports this test.
2 1 Mart, 11:26
Diğer 8

David King · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · All Saints RC School
Trolls no more?
4 1 Mart, 09:31

Brian Zaiger · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
Yeah right. Ever heard of sockpuppets?
· 1 Mart, 10:35

Max Marmer · Startup Genome'de Founder
Impressed with facebook's new commenting system for external sites. A lot of potential here. FB is kicking ass.
4 1 Mart, 16:23

Peggeth Loeb
FB wants to sell all your private info; should be opt in system
1 1 Mart, 16:33

Daniel Cho · Atlanta, Georgia
Look at all these comments!
4 1 Mart, 11:42

Paul Eulette 'divO' · Engauge'de Social Media Manager
These are ridic!
· 1 Mart, 11:57

Nicole Bogas · Blogads'ta Senior Strategist
Dan Cho!! hahaha this is so cool
· 2 Mart, 13:09

QuarterLife Magazine
Have you seen any other pages using this yet?
· 3 Mart, 04:04

Isabelle Mathieu
Le nouveau système de commentaires de Facebook est enfin arrivé! Il est donc possible de commenter avec son profil ou avec sa Page. Je commente ici avec ma Page sur un article de TC et mon commentaire s'affichera sur ma Page! Magique, non?
4 2 Mart, 00:31

Monsieur-Ciné Cruche · Celle de la vie
Magique ? Je ne sais pas. Mais voilà sans doute une option à envisager pour tout blogue qui se respecte !
· 12 Ekim, 18:19

Elliot Babchick · Stanford University
Sick
4 1 Mart, 13:20

it Lavi - Social Media Observer
Writing in the ne of your Page is also quite cool!
4 1 Mart, 23:50

Robert Grant · London, United Kingdom · 176 abone
This really is a ge changer.
4 2 Mart, 08:14

David Bass
Very Cool.

Thanks Robert!

-David
2 2 Mart, 09:02

Ad Jones · My Faceook Profile & click SUBSCRIBE!'da See FUNNY pics · 4.799 abone
Yeah, cheers rob
· 4 Mart, 03:57

Ozzie A. Gooen · Harvey Mudd College
Fun, but they're right about the need for Google and Twitter. Facebook is becoming to be seen kind of like Myspace.
3 1 Mart, 09:12

Patrick Giblin · San Diego, California
@451degrees is VERY interested in where this all will lead to...It is ALL about Graffiti! Bansky was NOT here!
3 1 Mart, 14:33

Bob Anderson · TV Magic, Inc.'da Executive VP/GM
I think Banksy WAS there . . . you just didn't see him!!!
· 1 Mart, 17:10

Gucci Mane's Face Tattoo
As Gucci Mane's ice cre cone face tattoo, I'm intrigued about this new feature and how it can help me get more fans.
3 1 Mart, 16:59

Jared Main Course Allen · Colorado State University
Good luck fuckboy!
· 1 Mart, 17:28

Tourism Currents
This is something for us to share right away with tourism and destination marketing clients. Wow.
3 1 Mart, 17:05

Dustin Luther
New Facebook comment option has some fascinating implications for marketing a business page...
3 1 Mart, 17:40

Dustin Luther · Dun & Bradstreet Credibility Corp.'da Head of Social Media
success! :)
1 2 Mart, 06:52

くりもと こうすけ · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · aaaa'da çalışıyor
使い道を考えてる。
3 2 Mart, 01:35

くりもと こうすけ · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · aaaa'da çalışıyor
コメントすると。
· 2 Mart, 01:39

Social Media Mma-Help for Business on FB
I LOVEE this feature thanks guys for sharing. Wow and look I can choose to post as my pages or myself, how cool is that? Will the @ tag work if I send out a big thanks to @MariSmith for bringing it to my attention? Hope so :-)
3 2 Mart, 20:38

Ken Evoy · SiteSell'de Founder
This puts Disqus and the others out of business. It's also going to put a huge dent in blog-commenting. When comments to your blog get shared with friends or fans, that's huge -- much better than third-party apps. When the comments to those comments are shared, that's incredible.

I never much believed in the value of commenting for most sites or blogs. This, though, is a total ge changer.

We'll be adding this as an option for our SBI! Clients. I'm sharing this with our 9,000 followers to see who well this works. :-)
...Devını Gör
4 14 Mart, 06:05

Christian Erwig-Straughan · Hilton, Ontario
Hi Ken,

It's really neat how your comments showed up in my personal news feed on Facebook. It seems like there are still a lot of bugs to be ironed out by Facebook, but the concept is brilliant.

All the best,

Christian
· 14 Mart, 06:15

SiteSell
I think I figure it out. You load the blog as an admin, and then choose to change the "Post as" options to your Facebook page, like I did here.

It's not a bug, just typical "figure-it-out" documentation by Facebook. VERY useful.
· 14 Mart, 06:32

John Dilbeck · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Dilbeck Marketing'de Owner
I see a lot of potential in this. When the new SBI site builder tool is rolled out, if this Facebook commenting system is an option, it will probably be the death of my blogs.

I enjoy the conversations on pages I write, but I don't like constantly updating WordPress (new updates, plug-ins, etc).

The fact that comments are seen on the page we write as well as our news feeds on Facebook makes this a big deal. I look forward to seeing how it plays out.
· 14 Mart, 08:01
Diğer 3

Spencer Chen · San Francisco, California · 192 abone
Note-to-self: Create fake Facebook account to continue TC trolling.
3 1 Mart, 09:27

Milo Yiannopoulos · Telegraph Media
GAYSIAN
1 1 Mart, 10:48

Spencer Chen · San Francisco, California · 192 abone
GAYGRE...ahhh, never mind!
· 1 Mart, 11:23
xmsrlong(Yahoo'yu kullanarak oturum açtı)
Get a yahoo account and troll away.
· 1 Mart, 18:50

David Pio · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Facebook'ta Partner-Engineer · 369 abone
FB will own all your opt in data the se way Google owns all your behavioral data.
3 1 Mart, 09:05

Indie is not a genre
Seems like you can comment as one of your pages as well. Shouldn't that count as sp.
3 1 Mart, 09:32

Brian Zaiger · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
Not if the comment has substance, although I don't see that happening very often.
· 1 Mart, 09:44

Simon Cross · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Facebook · 303 abone
I think it's pretty cool that, TechCrunch could reply to a comment thread as TechCrunch themselve... - thats the awesome use case...
1 1 Mart, 10:24

Jonathan Lally · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · San Francisco, California
I'm in your comment feed.. Trolling your articlez.
3 1 Mart, 09:47

Craig Coblenz · Syracuse
Congrats FB on another awesome product launch.
3 1 Mart, 09:44

John Panzer · University of California, Santa Cruz
The flood of test comments is not validating the "less sp" hypothesis.
3 1 Mart, 11:45

Will Cathcart · Facebook'ta Product Manager · 1.046 abone
at least it's different sp =)
· 1 Mart, 21:46

Mayank Gupta
This is very very interesting. Facebook comments :)
3 1 Mart, 10:58

Alex Berger · Travel Resource List.com'da Founder/Author
Definitely one way to ensure crazy numbers of new friend requests from random people.
3 1 Mart, 13:07

Andy Meyers · ASU
Teh comment on teh comment?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
· 1 Mart, 14:05

Vito Boscaino · Vito Boscaino'da Thinker in Chief
Great point.
· 1 Mart, 14:14

Sean Coleman · Blogic'de Founder & CEO
fancy seeing you here.
· 6 Mart, 22:33

Julian Müller · Facebook
This is nice.
3 1 Mart, 10:24

Keith Mander · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Google
Not too shabby.
1 1 Mart, 10:28

Keith Mander · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Google
Boomerang.
· 1 Mart, 10:28

Keith Mander · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Google
Hmm... comments here don't go back to TS.
· 1 Mart, 10:30
Diğer 2

Social Girl Media
The new comment system is Facebook's best invention, EVER.
3 1 Mart, 17:20

Kari Jordan
Have you seen Facebook's new comment system? Check it out at TechCrunch! This is not only a ge changer....it's revolutionary!

http://techcrunch.com/2011/03/01/facebook-rolls-out-overhauled-comments-system-try-them-now-on-techcrunch/
· 1 Mart, 17:21

Chris Haught · RC Painting Inc.'da Owner
Interesting!
2 1 Mart, 17:40

Kari Jordan
I like how when someone replies to my comment on TechCrunch's site, Facebook sends me a notification on my personal profile. GENIUS!
1 1 Mart, 17:41
Diğer 2

Ryan Mack · Facebook'ta Software Engineer
Oh hai. I need to test this. Hope it works. Kthxbai.
3 1 Mart, 17:43

Stephen Waits · San Diego, California
// @deprecated: disqus
· 1 Mart, 18:19

Olivier De Doncker · European Parlient'te Web Consultant
Testing Facebook comments system on techCrunch.
3 2 Mart, 02:41

Anuj Rathi · Flipkart'ta çalışıyor
Testing FB comment on blogs.
3 2 Mart, 01:57

lan K Mandal · IIT Kharagpur
abe how is this better than disqus or js-kit (echo)
· 2 Mart, 02:14

Nilesh Dadhich · Bangalore, India
That's a gud news guyz :)
· 2 Mart, 06:34

Phil Chbers · Podio'da CTO
Nice.
3 1 Mart, 23:36

Ed Lea
what up Phil, how's this comment stuff working out for you?
· 2 Mart, 06:07

Jonny Hinton · Seven Arts Leeds'te çalışıyor
Woah, cool. It's a pity I have nothing to say.
· 2 Mart, 07:44

Doug Monro · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · EBay
so the nonsense i usually post on fb (private) will now show up on techcrunch (public)? whooah, my professional creds will take a knock unless i can keep my mouth shut
· 2 Mart, 08:41
Diğer 4

heaven
We love this!
3 2 Mart, 06:28

Pinoy How To
We will apply this immediately on our website real great feature.
3 2 Mart, 18:23

Randolph Novino · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
great! we will be counting on this pinoyhowto
· 2 Mart, 18:30

Xeno Design
Wowieeee!
3 2 Mart, 14:17

Patti Garland · Xeno Design'de Strategist
This gives me chills!
2 2 Mart, 14:18

Michael Raudonikas · Saint Petersburg, Russia
The "..and it’s something that nobody else can do" part is not entirely correct. There is in fact someone.

This comment-syncing model is widely accepted on the Russian-speaking Internet, ever since Vkontakte.ru (Vk.com) – Facebook's chief competitor in the region – implemented a very similar widget last fall. http://vkontakte.ru/developers.php?o=-17680044&p=Comments (that one also allows you to post media items).
2 1 Mart, 10:29

Elisabeth Worthington
?
· 1 Mart, 12:24

Emmanuel Alquier · Paris, France
Je teste la nouvelle fonctionnalité de commentaire facebook. Vous voyez ce message dans votre flux d'actu? Si vous commentez, apparemment votre commentaire sera automatiquement publié sous le mien sur techcrunch.com.
2 1 Mart, 09:16

Jason Yoyotte Lapierre · Wipolo'da Embedded Systems engineer / UX Designer / iPhone-iPad guru
C'est génial ce truc tiens, j'en fais part à notre service de community managers ;)
· 1 Mart, 09:42

Coralie Jaunet
Jason, c'est toi le nouveau CM ;)
· 1 Mart, 09:56

Aymeric Auffray · ZIKPOT'da Founder/President
Ha ?
· 1 Mart, 14:23

Geoff Wright · Weartolook'ta Founder
Please get rid of this. I prefer Disqus. This pisses me off so much, I don't want my Facebook (friends) to be even nearly connected with my work/geek life. I don't see the advantages. Your AOL overlords have made this happen.

Come on techcrunch, you've let me down.
2 1 Mart, 09:59
techcrunchtroll(Yahoo'yu kullanarak oturum açtı)
this was an AOL directive and TC just folded.... Good job guys.... NOT....
· 1 Mart, 17:19

Al Tepper
Terrible idea to do this. Here's why:

1) Why would Google & Twitter join the party? For the first time they can make Facebook look like fools. Yahoo & Facebook is not enough to roll this out. I'll bet Techcrunch walk away from this and Facebook take it back into dev. There it will die. I would not run it on the sites I run for these very reasons. I very happy with Disqus.

2) On my wall give people a choice to reply 'Just On FB' OR 'On & Off FB' not just the latter.
...Devını Gör
2 1 Mart, 14:22

Al Tepper
4) The spacing formatting I applied on Techcrunch in my comment is gone.

Any more reasons needed? Facebook: backburner and more dev now. Before anyone really thinks this is a serious rollout and you lose face a la Google...(buzz/wave/latitude et al)
· 1 Mart, 14:24

Assem Jorges
You are the only clever in here... Please accept me as you friend, I so lonely... If you don't, well now I know your real ne... Na na na na na
· 1 Mart, 20:02

Makoto Sakata · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · 株式会社はちえん。　- ソーシャルメディアで人と人のご縁をまーるくつなぎます！ -'da 代表取締役 · 503 abone
新コメントプラグインのテスト
2 1 Mart, 16:51

Makoto Sakata · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · 株式会社はちえん。　- ソーシャルメディアで人と人のご縁をまーるくつなぎます！ -'da 代表取締役 · 503 abone
で、ここに返すと、Webにも反映される？
· 1 Mart, 16:51

Makoto Sakata · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · 株式会社はちえん。　- ソーシャルメディアで人と人のご縁をまーるくつなぎます！ -'da 代表取締役 · 503 abone
うわ、すご！
· 1 Mart, 16:52

Go Toshihiro · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · 株式会社日本情報化農業研究所'da 執行役員（マーケティング担当） · 142 abone
A test of Leave Comments thank you;^)
1 1 Mart, 17:36
Diğer 1

Dave Fleet · Edelman
Interesting that, with the new 'Facebook Pages as people' functionality, companies' Facebook Pages can now comment on external sites and have those comments aggregated on the pages themselves. It'll be interesting to see how that dynic plays out.
2 1 Mart, 17:09

Barb Chberlain · Spokane, Washington
I'm going to test this feature & post this comment to my FB profile--where I just posted a link to a blog post I wrote WARNING my friends about this: http://bit.ly/hRXElK.

So, dear friends, if you comment on this comment, make SURE you know where your words are appearing: inside Facebook, or out here on TechCrunch.com where I'm originating the link.

I don't think the problem of people inadvertently sending private comments out to the world is at all a small one.
...Devını Gör
2 2 Mart, 19:19

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
This is excellent news. I hope it doesn't hurt other commenting systems which have spent a lot of time and money. I hope they will be clear up the Twitter and Google situation.

It really needs FB's privacy lock so we can limit who can see it on FB.
2 1 Mart, 09:16

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
This is a test of the reciprocal comments.
· 1 Mart, 09:18

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
Will this cause more people to break FB's rules and make multiple accounts so they can troll etc?
· 1 Mart, 09:21

Trevis Thirdgill · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · University of Oregon
GE CHANGER.
· 1 Mart, 09:29
Diğer 6

McLane Creative
This could be a ge-changer. We won't be rolling it into any of our sites until there is a plugin though. At the se time, I dig that they've combined the "share" and "recommend/like" button on sites.
2 1 Mart, 09:47

Awais Imran · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
It's definitely a nice idea, but I know A LOT of people who'd like to keep their Facebook IDs private. So it just might be counter-productive!
2 1 Mart, 09:31

Geoff Hines
This is terrible. Dreadful in fact. This is worse than the Gawker 2.0 release. Goodbye Techcrunch. Nice knowing you.
2 1 Mart, 09:13

Kevin W Miller
I like the idea, now I don't have to have several different accounts floating around just to comment on something.
2 1 Mart, 09:26

Jewel Abdul Kader · Jersey City, New Jersey
The major problem in facebook social plug-ins is, they are putting lots of links in these to bring hosting sites traffics to facebook.
2 1 Mart, 09:59

ith Narendra · EMC Corporation'da çalışıyor
I like Facebook comments & how that is leveraged like this... let the world be better commented :-)
2 1 Mart, 09:44

Jeslin Joy · SDM College of Engineering and Technology
Sooper
· 1 Mart, 09:47

Micah Daigle · San Francisco, California
I received a notification on Facebook that two people replied to my comment. I ce back here and my comment was gone!
2 1 Mart, 11:23

Nizeddin Haşim Ordulu · MIT
What is actually missing in this comment system in comparison to disqus other than anonymous commenting?
2 1 Mart, 11:59

Ryan Mack · Facebook'ta Software Engineer
Testing the whole "This comment will also be posted to TechCrunch" thing.
· 1 Mart, 12:25

Harrison Fisk · Facebook'ta MySQL Database Engineer
Seems pretty neat!
· 1 Mart, 12:46

Nizeddin Haşim Ordulu · MIT
So is this going to appear on TC too?
· 1 Mart, 13:25
Diğer 4

Mohul Ghosh · MBIC
Wow! Sounds yummy to me.. Atleast, spmers posting bg blue pill would think twice now :) I 'like' it!
2 1 Mart, 11:46

Mohul Ghosh · MBIC
testing one two three... :)
· 1 Mart, 11:50

Mohul Ghosh · MBIC
ok.. I liked this post here.. and commented.. and its visible on TechCrunch! Breakthrough development :)
· 1 Mart, 11:51

Vishal Vivek · SEO Corporation'da Chief Business Officer
its great...
· 1 Mart, 13:36
Diğer 4

Kathleen Sheehan · New York, New York
Transparency is key, said Charlie Sheen, Eric Schmidt & Mark Zuckerberg.
2 1 Mart, 12:12

Pela French · New York, New York
what do you think of this http://www.socialeyes.com/?
· 8 Mart, 16:17

Wendy Herndon · Keller Willis Real Estate'de Real Estate Agent/Realtor
Testing out the new Facebook commenting feature Tech Crunch. Looks azing!
2 1 Mart, 16:22

Assem Jorges
WTF Facebook... All the world now have 2 accounts, who are you kidding? This is an account that I have with my REAL NE (oh yeahhhhh) :D
2 1 Mart, 19:52

Jenn Allen · Rtist.com'da Founder, CEO · 349 abone
To overcome the noise barrier to effective communication, one must discover its source -- thanks, facebook's new commenting plugin! Will use this on RTist asap.
2 1 Mart, 21:54

Nathan Latka · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Lujure'de Founder and CEO · 226 abone
Great move by Facebook! Looking forward to embracing this in our site once roll out is complete.
2 1 Mart, 21:42

Cory Shanes · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Cory Shanes - The 24/7 Entrepreneur'da Internet Entrepreneur
I agree Nathan - These comments rock.
2 2 Mart, 03:27

Isabelle Mathieu · 163 abone
That's awesome! Now that the new Facebook comments system has been launched, the question is "which comment system will you use on your blog?" : 1. Disqus 2.Echo 3.Facebook Pls Vote! ;-)
2 2 Mart, 00:01

Vincent Rostaing · Nantes, France
Disqus
· 2 Mart, 00:32

Isabelle Mathieu · 163 abone
Merci ! Pourquoi ?
· 2 Mart, 00:34

Ka Rin · Data Pro Proximity'de Digital Marketing Manager
Powerful tool for increasing branded engagement and awareness in social media.
2 2 Mart, 00:18

Yehonatan Lebel
Super cool Karin, Lets try this at home
· 2 Mart, 00:44

Joey Seroussi · Digital lab'da Manager
the network just got bigger again.
Looks like a great opportunity for marketers and, of course, another jewel in facebook's crown.
· 2 Mart, 00:49

Ido Kenan · The 7th Eye'de Web Presence Manager, Columnist and Reporter · 1.155 abone
הממ..
· 3 Mart, 03:58
Diğer 1

Martin Eriksson
As much as this is competition for Disqus et al, this will also push Facebook as your single online identity. Personally I prefer Facebook to be private and Twitter to be my public/work facing identity, but all of a sudden that's not possible...
2 2 Mart, 06:49

Fabio De Bernardi · Synthesio'da Senior Account Manager
+1. A while ago I realised how Twitter is the best public profile to send people to when I comment on blogs...
· 2 Mart, 14:34

Shailendra Sharma · IIT Kharagpur
The power of Facebook now showing up.. Forget anonymity and be ready to post your identity all over the web!
2 2 Mart, 08:24

Iffort
It is an excellent move by Facebook. Strong indication of the fact they are not trying to move beyond the user-base that is already there on the Social platform itself.
2 4 Mart, 04:39

Tabrez Ansari · Iffort'ta Software Developer
azing post:)
· 4 Mart, 05:18

Tabrez Ansari · Iffort'ta Software Developer
Hi :)
· 4 Mart, 05:21

Sunny Jindal · New Delhi, India
Thanks Guys!
· 4 Mart, 05:25
Diğer 1

Sunny Jindal · New Delhi, India
I think this is a brilliant move and will redefine the way communication happens..
2 4 Mart, 05:27

Paras Mendiratta · Bangalore, India
Nice
· 5 Mart, 10:36

Siddharth Parwatay · St. Xavier's College
Trying out Facebook's new commenting system that syndicates content both ways... Social commenting - nice concept, will it click?
2 6 Mart, 06:07

Franklin McMahon · Franklin McMahon Studio'da Creative Director · 112 abone
Very handy. I have had Facebook comments as well as DISQUS comments on my blog for a while now. Trying to decide which to go with. Has anyone switched? Pros, cons?
2 7 Mart, 06:32

Michal Dudek · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Wrocław
So basically non-facebook users have their mouth shut, now? :/
2 1 Mart, 09:40

Benjin Roodman · Missouri University of Science and Technology
::Bullshit comment test to see how this looks in Facebook::
2 1 Mart, 09:34

Helge Fahrnberger · 124 abone
So comments show up at the top? Rewrite the pattern books everybody ;-).
2 1 Mart, 10:52

Andreas Klinger · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Lookk.com'da Co-Founder
I kinda like the cross commenting and the fact that friends are at the top. Kinda slow yet doh ;)
· 1 Mart, 11:35

Helge Fahrnberger · 124 abone
Totally screws discussion flow though. Weird. Maybe we'll get used to it, grace to the ubiquitous Facebook.
· 1 Mart, 12:51

Martin Schobert · Tourismusdesign'de Managing Director
Jo habe die Ehre is des viral. Yes - I very proud to reognize this azing feature as an early adopter. Great stuff!
· 1 Mart, 15:56
Diğer 3

iStrategyLabs
I think I hate this. But then again I'm just a lowly Facebook page so who cares how I feel right?
2 1 Mart, 11:27

Chester Zik Daniel · Greensboro, North Carolina
Great concept. This will take off.
2 1 Mart, 09:10

Tysone Scott
School me one more time my brotha'! I have no idea what is going on. I still a facebook neophyte.
· 2 Mart, 02:57

Ri Reyes · UPenn
Testing out the new Facebook comments.
2 1 Mart, 09:56

Chip Wainginn · Georgia Teknoloji Enstitüsü
Hmm...looks like they just changed how the fb:comments tag is handled.
2 1 Mart, 12:01

Corey DonCorsean Ricketts · Royal Caribbean Cruises
All your comments are belong to us...
2 1 Mart, 10:07

Michael Rihani · Koofers'te Co-Founder and Chief Strategy Officer · 219 abone
The web is becoming a lot less anonymous!
2 1 Mart, 11:32

Frederick Cook · Washington, District of Columbia
Seems to be a draw-back that there are only two tiers here. Doesn't facilitate a back-and-forth discussion between individuals very well.
1 1 Mart, 16:12

Lujure
Totally agree with you Fred!
· 1 Mart, 21:35

Mohit Vora
Weave weave weave...
2 1 Mart, 10:16

Matt Schlicht · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · San Francisco, California · 208 abone
Where is the up/down voting?
2 1 Mart, 11:12

Ali Feinstein · Gin Lane Media'da çalışıyor
Testing testing
2 1 Mart, 10:31

Si Kuusela · Sofanatics'te Creative Director/Co-Founder
I want Facebook to tap my phone.
2 1 Mart, 11:18

Sergei Burkov · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology
"Comments left by friends will float to the top" -- this is huge.
2 1 Mart, 14:32

FB C# SDK
Page comment test.
2 1 Mart, 12:21

Nathan Totten · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Microsoft'ta Technical evangelist · 206 abone
Test response
· 1 Mart, 12:21

Carlos Henrique Guardão Gandarez · Analista Progrador'da Landz Tecnologia
Ihuulll :) nice!
· 1 Mart, 12:22

Maciek Misztal
works
· 1 Mart, 12:27
Diğer 3

Yaron Sid · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · BillGuard'da Founder & CEO
I wonder if this will work for ssl web apps.
2 1 Mart, 14:14

Ron Gura · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · EBay'da Head of Israel Social Center
crazy stuff.
1 1 Mart, 15:12

Gadi BenMark · New York, New York
Good crazy or bad crazy?
· 1 Mart, 15:47

Ron Gura · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · EBay'da Head of Israel Social Center
i dunno
guess good :)
· 1 Mart, 15:58

Mads Dørup · Trustpilot'ta Lead Developer
These pretzels are making me thirsty!
2 1 Mart, 15:13

Andrea Ball
Interesting!
2 1 Mart, 14:33

Ankur Jain · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Toronto, Ontario
Nice a lot of people have jumped in on it.
· 1 Mart, 15:14

Ario Jafarzadeh · Google
I want my homies comments to show up first in the stack.
2 1 Mart, 17:46

Ario Jafarzadeh · Google
what, I can't leave a comment that just stays on my FB page??
2 1 Mart, 17:46

Erin (Kanaley) Fularo · Starting Up a StartUp'ta çalışıyor · 563 abone
Pretty sweet... new is always fun :)
2 1 Mart, 17:17

JeRe Reading
Hey, Rob, read up on this!
2 1 Mart, 17:53

JeRe Reading
I think it's a hit.
1 1 Mart, 17:58

Rob Ashby · Seattle, Washington
Wha?
· 1 Mart, 18:02

John MacIntyre
whoa
· 1 Mart, 18:19
Diğer 1

Sumanth Thikka · BITS, Pilani - Goa
It's a really good feature! Powerful!
2 1 Mart, 22:52

Nilesh Ajwelkar · True Sparrow Systems'te çalışıyor
You sure? Trying it now.
· 2 Mart, 01:21

Nishith Shah · True Sparrow'da CEO & Founder
hmm.. It isn't loading for me.
· 2 Mart, 02:04

Simon Nicholson · Maidenhead
This needs a linkedin option!
2 2 Mart, 06:09

Karan Singh · Yrals'ta Manager
This looks cool.
2 1 Mart, 09:57

Seema Bir
I'll check it out!
· 1 Mart, 09:58

Saurabh Chhabra · Qanect Communications'ta Social Media and IT
Interesting :\
2 1 Mart, 11:08

Ken Mueller · Lancaster, Pennsylvania
I think I like this!
2 1 Mart, 12:23

Taimur Asghar · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Lulz Truck'ta Shiz Master
Test!
2 1 Mart, 09:22

John Gabaix
double testing
· 1 Mart, 12:31

PixelCog Inc.
This is pretty cool!
2 1 Mart, 15:08

Erick Laubach · Cuteness.com'da Founder
Neato
2 1 Mart, 11:56

Darla Brown
Interesting analysis.
· 1 Mart, 11:58

Darla Brown
don't delete me
· 1 Mart, 12:00

Maureen Conger · Culver City, California
Cool that friends comments show up first
1 1 Mart, 12:38
Diğer 2

John Smithmod · Test'te çalışıyor
Test
2 1 Mart, 10:42

Assem Jorges
Are you the se f u c king John Smith that is everywhere in the world? WOOOOW nice to meet you John... My ne is Assem and I want to be your friend on Facebook... I loooooooove Facebook, I can find all the shit I want there... Yuuppiiiii
1 1 Mart, 20:01

Atsuhiko Takahashi · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · さぶみっと！JAPAN'da Attrip
It is nice.
2 1 Mart, 16:06

Atsuhiko Takahashi · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · さぶみっと！JAPAN'da Attrip
おお！
1 1 Mart, 16:22

Kenshiro Tsuge · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Osaka-shi, Osaka, Japan
おじゃましまーす。これはいい感じ！
· 1 Mart, 18:26

Atsuhiko Takahashi · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · さぶみっと！JAPAN'da Attrip
おぉ！これは、いい感じですなー
1 1 Mart, 18:29
Diğer 3

Takeshi Hirano · Koto-ku, Tokyo, Japan
Comment Test
2 1 Mart, 17:56

Nobuo Takahashi · 自営（オフィス復氷）'da çalışıyor
Wow, your comment comes first.
1 1 Mart, 18:12

Atsuhiko Takahashi · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · さぶみっと！JAPAN'da Attrip
ここへの返事が素敵な件
2 1 Mart, 18:29

Nobuo Takahashi · 自営（オフィス復氷）'da çalışıyor
なるほど、fbのストリームに現れました。
1 1 Mart, 18:41
Diğer 2

SeaBass
Who threw the salt?
2 1 Mart, 19:14

Warren Whitlock · Profitable Social Media Radio Show'da Host · 300 abone
Lovely
2 1 Mart, 16:33

Sandy Harper · Gratitude Boot Cp'ta Realtor at Century 21 and Author - Speaker - Ghostwriter - Gratitude Coach · 191 abone
It's lovely to reply to your reply, Warren!!
· 1 Mart, 19:44

Warren Whitlock · Profitable Social Media Radio Show'da Host · 300 abone
I never knew we could have such a lovely conversation on Techcrunch.. but I'm back based on a notification on Facebook

I want this on my blog!
· 1 Mart, 21:02

Jack Zhao · Palo Alto, California
Cool
2 1 Mart, 14:27

Coral Asl
No Way!
2 1 Mart, 16:25

Coral Asl
This is scary :D I thinking of shutting down my facebook account!
· 1 Mart, 18:14

Jeff Iden · Facebook'ta Global Marketing Solutions · 131 abone
Comments are fun!
2 1 Mart, 21:52

Vincent Fabre
So cool
2 2 Mart, 02:20

Steven O'Brien · CBS High School
Like buttons on TechCrunch? That's fine, nobody's forcing me to use it. Facebook commenting on TechCrunch, and every other blog I ever bother to comment on? That disturbs me. I love commenting on blogs and participating in the conversation, but I don't want all this data going through facebook for obvious reasons. Seriously, you can already log into facebook via disqus if you really want to, so why change the commenting system to something inferior?
1 1 Mart, 09:28

Steven O'Brien · CBS High School
Oh wow, great job facebook for publishing the ne of my school to TechCrunch...
4 1 Mart, 09:30

Nathan Wong · Gravitywell'de Developer
You might want to make that private information on your Facebook profile then.
· 1 Mart, 09:48

Steven O'Brien · CBS High School
It is...
1 1 Mart, 10:40
Diğer 1

Vitalii Daniuk · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · КНЕУ
This feature will bring local social networks to its knees because websites will install only one social commenting system and facebook has the best reach to bring additional traffic to the websites.

For exple russian Facebook clone Vkontakte has similar commenting system, but social network sharing features are much weaker, thus ensuring webmaster support for Facebook comments.
1 1 Mart, 13:24

Yasuo Yao · Cereja Technology'da Founder, CEO
新しいコメントシステム、うちのサイトにも入れなくては。
1 1 Mart, 16:49

Katsuyuki Takahashi · Nikkei BP'da çalışıyor
OnAirする前の事前Checkみたいなことはできないンだろーなー。
1 1 Mart, 17:29

Miki Yot · 日本ビジネスプレス'da çalışıyor
それしちゃうと、オープンな議論にならないですもんね。
1 1 Mart, 17:55

Katsuyuki Takahashi · Nikkei BP'da çalışıyor
おぉ、みきちゃん、この日本語でのやりとり、自分のFacebook上だと何ともないけど、TechCrunch(英語)サイトで見ると、とても違和感ありますねー。
· 1 Mart, 18:03

Miki Yot · 日本ビジネスプレス'da çalışıyor
私も同じこと考えてました。きっと英語圏の人には下位にリストされるんでしょうね。
· 1 Mart, 18:34
Diğer 1

Norio Shimizu · ピクシブ株式会社'da UI/UX Designer
空気を読まずに日本語で投稿してみるテスト。こいつは非常に強力な機能ですね。
1 2 Mart, 02:47

Taisei Okazaki
Ruby forum 2008ではいろいろとありがとうございました。覚えていらっしゃいますでしょうか？
· 2 Mart, 03:05

Yusuke Sakaki · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · 30min. Inc.'da エンジニア
ほう。ちゃんとリプライも出来るのですね。
· 8 Mart, 18:26

Jeff Schneider · Marketing Ninjas'ta Founder, Director
I really, REALLY like the idea of using Facebook for a commenting system, but my biggest concern, one that's happened using Disqus in the past, is what happens if something goes wrong and their system goes down? With Disqus, suddenly all the comments on the blog posts were gone. When I use WordPress' built-in commenting system, those comments are in MY system on MY site. So as excited as I to see this, there's still a bit of a concern about that. And yes, as mentioned in the article, some people will not want to post a comment as themselves in Facebook.
1 2 Mart, 11:13

Ay Bee
Oh...I C...you mean I'm slowly being FORCED to use a FB or Yahoo or Twitter account in order to make a comment or have my say? This is outrageous! Must surely be close to the end of privacy now...maybe the end of democracy as we believe it to be. Wow! They've really got us by the boom boom! Beyond that, the re-posting of the exact se info to additional web pages or accounts is ridiculous! A bit like double handling. Also means that information will be doubled, tripled, quadrupled etc everywhere and may remain in existence for many years to come...in time, slowly clogging up the net with absolute crap! People should really get the point that 99% of all comments/ blogs are only ever read by the author!
1 7 Mart, 16:46

Lee McIntosh · Reach Business Ltd'da Director
So funny seeing everyone moaning about this Facebook Comment system, Facebook taking over, being 'disturbed' by Facebook and Facebook general privacy setting.. Come on peeps, if you don't want to use it, nobody is forcing you! Sheep!
1 1 Mart, 09:45

Borys Musielak · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
530 comments and counting. Wit no comment karma or other means of emphasizing the important content, this is going to totally kill commenting on popular websites like TechCrunch. Do it like they do it on Slashdot or don't do it at all.
On the other hand, it can be a real killer feature for small sites that normally would have zero or very few comments, with all interactions moving to Facebooks and Twitters or the world.
1 1 Mart, 11:56

Bartłomiej Dymecki · Okazje.info'da çalışıyor
Najwyraźniej chcą zając dla siebie wszystko co się wiąże ze społecznymi aktywnościi userów. I nie wiem czy się tego nie bać ;)
· 1 Mart, 12:34

Borys Musielak · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
aż na blogasku o tym skrobnąłem: http://osblog.pl/facebook-comments-czyli-przejecie-kontroli-nad-swiatem-teraz/
· 1 Mart, 12:37

Bartłomiej Dymecki · Okazje.info'da çalışıyor
Co ciekawe, mój komentarz puszczony tutaj wyświetla się na techcrunchu, idą na całość :)
· 1 Mart, 12:48

Scott Dunlap · PayPal'da VP, Emerging Opportunities
Just imagine - this can help find all the assholes that just say negative things about everything. You can just click on their profile and see where they comment everywhere. Me like more than FB like!
1 1 Mart, 10:41

Francine Hardaway · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Columbia Üniversitesi · 202 abone
My FB friends and my Tech Crunch friends are almost entirely different, so I'm not sure how they will like seeing my geeky side exposed. For people my age, that's almost as bad as being nude.
1 1 Mart, 11:19

Kevin Gawthrope · Chandler, Arizona
LOL!
· 1 Mart, 12:47

Tyler Hurst · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · AntiPRguy'da Actual writer. Event planner. Mischief maker. Speaker.
I'm not a fan of this. Not at all.
· 1 Mart, 13:03

Sean McCloskey
Its bad enough the internet never deletes your old information, but now we have comment sections which will display our current image and ne. Seems ripe for a worm to collect FB login or user id numbers to say the least which can then be manipulated in other tools to cause all sorts of havoc.
1 1 Mart, 13:11

Mattias Tyrberg · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Saplo'da CEO
Now you can use Facebook to comment directly on web sites. If you answer on this comment it will automatically be posted both on Facebook and on TechCrunch. So smart and awesome! #like
1 1 Mart, 12:23

Anders Fredriksson · Gothenburg
bye bye disqus...
· 1 Mart, 13:34

Mattias Tyrberg · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Saplo'da CEO
Agree, Disqus will have big big problems to survive this...
· 1 Mart, 14:37

Petter Palander · badoo'da Founder
Our kids won't know what internet is/was. It changed ne to facebook in the mid 2011 :D
· 1 Mart, 21:31

Doniree Walker · University of Minnesota
Interesting, and I'd love to try this but that "one big flaw" will probably keep me waiting. I love the possible integration and relationship between Facebook and my blogs, however - Facebook can't be the only way people can login/comment.
1 1 Mart, 14:21

Juan Pablo Lanteri · Villa Carlos Paz
One caveat: the user can´t choose what URL associate with the comment (Its alway the facebook page for that user).

And sometimes in different situations you want to leave different URLs.
1 1 Mart, 14:02

AlishaOutridge.com
Facebook's new external comment system is great for one reason: it enables Companies to have an identity and comment easily out on the web which will provide new ways for Community & Facebook page managers to share relevant content to their fans.
1 1 Mart, 14:59

Alisha Outridge-Simonovic · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Manhattan, New York
By the way, I posted the comment above using my Facebook Brand page and now I'm commenting using my personal profile page.
· 1 Mart, 15:00

Alisha Outridge-Simonovic · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Manhattan, New York
Even better = brand nes & thumbnail pics change here in the commenting module after you've posted the comment if you've changed it on your Facebook page
· 1 Mart, 15:03

AlishaOutridge.com
That is really neat Alisha :-)
· 1 Mart, 15:04

Brian Ries · 1.775 abone
Must say...to think trolls are going away shows you haven't spent much time moderating a Facebook fan page. They're still there. Only difference is the trolls now have nes.
1 1 Mart, 15:30

Taehee Lee · Atlanta, Georgia
Wow! It's azing. Techcrunch comment with facebook account. 페이스북 계정으로 댓글을 다는 이 시스템이 한국의 포털과 언론사에도 도입되기를.. 악플 방지에 큰 기여를 할 듯.
1 1 Mart, 20:03

Haedong Park · Seoul, Korea
거기서 IT 제대로 하시는구만. 어여 돌아오세요... 구심점이 없으니 지지부진한 듯...
· 1 Mart, 20:09

Taehee Lee · Atlanta, Georgia
ㅎㅎㅎ 이거 재밌네요. 댓글 놀이가 페이스북에서 테크크런치까지 이어지는. 영민이랑 한잔 잘 하셨나요..^^
· 4 Mart, 20:38

Haedong Park · Seoul, Korea
어여 돌아와라... 앞으로 먹고 살 사업구상까지 끝~ 이제 실행만 남았다 ㅋㅋㅋ
· 4 Mart, 20:43

Dialogue
Yep- Facebook is rolling out this new commenting feature over here on TechCrunch, and it's terrific. Thanks for sharing Mari Smith. Page Administrators take notice!
1 1 Mart, 18:52

Tyson Goodridge · Boston, Massachusetts
Yep- this is showing up on Techcrunch...
· 2 Mart, 06:52

MasterMind Marketing Solutions (M3S)
I love the potential for versatile social interaction with this new feature. And the ability to comment "as a page" or as yourself makes the new comment platform very flexible.
1 1 Mart, 22:39

Erno Hannink - Social Media for Independent Professionals
This is cool, of course at discuss I can easilly find my comments on the various websites. On Facebook it will be somewhere in all my updates. And switching to the personal profiel or page is easy too.
1 2 Mart, 00:02

Ashwani Gaur · PlayCez'de Founder
Some Facebook applications, like http://apps.facebook.com/playcez already integrates with FB comments system very beautifully. But a native support is a great news :)
1 2 Mart, 03:21

森下治秀 · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
これが新しいコメントシステムか？
1 2 Mart, 07:50

森下治秀 · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
そーです
· 2 Mart, 07:50

Smart Insights
Great tool - certainly ge changing and Facebook stepping further towards being an online 'passport' - must be a worry for some tech companies running similar services.
1 2 Mart, 08:24

Jes Tharpe · Rollins Inc.'da Sr. Marketing IT Manager
Whoa... I'd be interested to see an analysis of the trade-off between the SEO impact of Facebook comments (which you lose) and the social impact of Facebook comments (which you gain).
1 2 Mart, 09:39

Nikhil Thorat · Google'de Software Engineer
Dn. Disqus is going to be dead after this. Especially because you can weed out trollers.. This is a step for facebook in the right direction... now if only they could put this much thought into their photo viewing system on Facebook itself...
1 2 Mart, 14:57

Robert Holland · Athens, Georgia
Here's a "step-by-step" I just finished on how to get Facebook's new commenting system to work on your Wordpress blog > http://socialmediaseo.net/2011/03/02/add-facebook-comments-wordpress/ - hope it helps.
1 2 Mart, 16:35

D.j. Heckes · Albuquerque, New Mexico
What a great new plug in to allow those who love to comment with value content to be recognized by their real ne and this will show who steps up and plays in the big field or who continues to post comments that are not relevant and nto spming and selling in your face.
1 5 Mart, 13:20

Edward Shenderovich
We had first implemented a similar feature with LiveJournal back in May of 2007. It significantly increased commenting right away.
1 1 Mart, 09:07

Tony Curzon Price · London, United Kingdom
arghh - openDemocracy has just done a whole port of all our comments to Disqus, and now we have to move again!
· 1 Mart, 11:39

Asy Patrysheva · Travel.ru'da çalışıyor
Edward! is it still work with lj? where i can see it?
· 7 Mart, 08:37

Edward Shenderovich
Here you go: http://www.kommersant.ru/doc.aspx?DocsID=1597222
· 7 Mart, 10:59

Brian Waterkotte · Northern Kentucky University
Posting a message on Tech Crunch, using the new Facebook Comment System...does anyone really care? I'm guessing no.
1 1 Mart, 09:34

Jim Harris · Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters
I care!
· 1 Mart, 10:38

Andy Oleszczuk · Chicago, Illinois
Where s the big ass low post threat been ?
· 1 Mart, 11:13

Bryan Monroe · 25 Kids'te CEO & Founder
This will be really useful for smaller sites who just want an easy comment plugin and facebook integration all-in-one.
1 1 Mart, 09:42

Matthew E. Russo · Blast Brand'da Principal/Founder
Seems well-integrated. Looking forward to seeing how sites/individuals implement this.
1 1 Mart, 09:47

Grant Miller · Los Angeles, California
yeah, should be interesting (though, the fact that i'm leaving this on your wall & it is posting to an external site is going to spook people who think it is private)
2 1 Mart, 16:57

Mike Flynn · Answers.com'da çalışıyor
The only thing missing from the new Facebook comments is the ability to import comments from another system.
1 1 Mart, 09:38

Brad Hogenmiller · Infuz'da Director of Social Media
Wonder how these fold into analytics?
· 1 Mart, 14:48

Mike Pearce · Kab'da Software Engineer
It's going to be interesting how this changes commenting systems and how widely it gets rolled out across the internets.
1 1 Mart, 09:58

Doncho Angelov · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Milestone Systems'te Development and Site Manager
If it does not support well Google, Twitter and most probably Wordpress.com, I doubt this will be huge success, if at all.
1 1 Mart, 10:04

Димитър Цонев · Сдружение на артистите "Адаптация"'da PR
а тази глупост, че ти публикува по подразбиране на стената, не те ли дразни?
· 1 Mart, 10:08

Doncho Angelov · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Milestone Systems'te Development and Site Manager
It's not by default, it's not only on my wall (but also on the post!), and you can turn it off.
And it does not bother me :)
· 1 Mart, 10:15
Diğer 2

Strat.in - Strategy Invented, Strategy Indianised
Fabulous commenting system indeed! Should drive more traffic to blogs this way - particularly utilising the social graph...
1 1 Mart, 11:15

Nit Gupta · Theitechblog'da Founder/Editor
When will this new Facebook comment system will be available for all? Can this be added along with the default comment system of WordPress?
1 1 Mart, 11:31

Dan Voell · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Ge Changa

Can't imagine why a blog would not want to implement this. It's an easy way to get conversation from outside of your blog.
1 1 Mart, 11:29

Dan Voell · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Aside from the lost content on your blog.
· 1 Mart, 11:34
Diğer 3

Mike Templeton · Kum & Go'da Social Media Manager
The best feature is that it attributes comments under your real ne and identity. I'm all for ridding the internet of trolling anonymous users.
1 1 Mart, 12:57

Ben Stone · Your Techy Friend'de Owner
I applaud this big step towards addressing the comment troll issue. I'm torn between FB seeming like a force of good and then I feel like it's turning into Big Brother.
· 1 Mart, 13:55
Diğer 2

Shauna Stacy · ASU
Looking forward to watching everyone's friends' thoughtless random comments be publicly displayed on prominent news sites!
1 1 Mart, 14:13

Marc Quinn · Self Employed Entrepreneur'da Web Designer
My ne is Marc Quinn and I endorse this comment...
· 1 Mart, 14:16

Alex Berger · Travel Resource List.com'da Founder/Author
I see you Shauna....
· 1 Mart, 14:27

Marijean Jaggers · Jaggers Communications'ta Owner/ President
This may be the right solution to the comment on the blog vs. Facebook situation that comes up so frequently. I'm willing to give it a try.
1 1 Mart, 13:40

Sean Michael McCord · University of Virginia'da AV System Engineer
Very interesting. I need to find the time to revp my (too many) WP sites in order to integrate these features.
· 2 Mart, 07:18

Carlo Ritschl · Republic Financial'da Marketing Specialist
WOW, I wonder how many companies are going to switch over to this. Word of mouth will be on fire. (commenting on pages outside of facebook!)
1 1 Mart, 13:59

Tav Espian
Do comments on here turn up on your profile's activity stre? If so, where's the option to opt-out of that behaviour?
1 1 Mart, 13:43

Luke Graybill · Provo, Utah
It seems pretty clear to me. The comment button even makes it stupid-simple.. it says "Comment on TechCrunch". Pretty plain to me that this will be going out to the world (of course, I knew that already by posting a comment anywhere on the internet). I don't understand what the problem is.
· 1 Mart, 14:07

Al Tepper
Terrible idea to do this. Here's why:

1) Why would Google & Twitter join the party? For the first time they can make Facebook look like fools. Yahoo & Facebook is not enough to roll this out. I'll bet Techcrunch walk away from this and Facebook take it back into dev. There it will die. I would not run it on the sites I run for these very reasons. I very happy with Disqus.

2) On my wall give people a choice to reply 'Just On FB' OR 'On & Off FB' not just the latter.
...Devını Gör
2 1 Mart, 14:27

Luke Graybill · Provo, Utah
Your 5th point makes the argument that web services shouldn't expand their features because some users might be too ignorant to understand them? That's ridiculous; if people can't understand how the internet works, then they need to educate themselves. They shouldn't be used as munition to stall progress.
· 1 Mart, 15:00
Diğer 6

Louis Broome · Microsoft'ta Content Publishing Manager, Office UA
This is a test. For this comment only, this commentor will conduct a test of the Facebook comments system. This is only a test.
1 1 Mart, 15:02

Doug Kim · Microsoft
I like it that my friends are on top. So to speak.
· 1 Mart, 16:02

Doug Thomas · Microsoft
Errrrarrrrrrr....
· 1 Mart, 16:40
galileo17(Yahoo'yu kullanarak oturum açtı)
Might as well send some hair and skin sples into FB... they're trying to capture everything else possibly unique to me...
1 1 Mart, 15:26

Allison Fuller Moore · Sacrento, California
Testing Facebook's new comment features. Read about it on Techcrunch.com: Facebook Rolls Out Overhauled Comments System.
1 1 Mart, 16:32

Allison Fuller Moore · Sacrento, California
And now testing leaving a comment. Not only will this show up here (on FB) but now you'll see FB comments in a thread on the original website.
· 1 Mart, 16:34

FatCowBusiness.com Internet Marketing Tips
Awesome can't wait to implement this for comments on our wordpress blog... anyone know where can we download this? Or is there a release date? Cheers
1 2 Mart, 03:12

Dave Cupples · Sydney, Australia
Testing ... so if I comment here on Facebook this should appear on the blog site as well!!
1 2 Mart, 03:13

Jérémie Lannoy · Emakina'da Account Director
Really like it, read complains about this just this morning and we were searching a solution for this for so long with devs.
1 2 Mart, 07:10

Biz Eez Virtual Solutions
Love the fact you can post as either your FB Profile or Page. Loads more opporunities for business. Also think it will encourage the quality of feedback. Let's see!
1 4 Mart, 15:42

Marianne Braunack · Pindarie'de Communications Officer
It is weird because there are some times that I logged on as "Pindarie" and I kind of forget and I will be about to make a personal comment on something and then I have to check myself, as you have to be aware that you are representing a business... I sound a little neurotic here!!! lol Glad I don't represent more than 1 business :)
2 4 Mart, 15:51

Chris Gwillis · Cardiff
Feels weird being the first person to comment on this, but I loving the concept. True social aggregation.
1 1 Mart, 09:03

Michael Wertheim · MDW Digital Ventures'te CEO & President
Interesting. Should ultimately change the tenor of commenting if it's no longer anonymous.
1 1 Mart, 09:29

Noah Mittman · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Ogilvy
Also interesting is the social graph weighting: Your post showed up as third in the list after the two most FacebookMojoed non-friend comments.
· 3 Mart, 16:12

Michael Wertheim · MDW Digital Ventures'te CEO & President
Wait - so does that mean that I have a lot, or a little mojo?
· 3 Mart, 21:02

Noah Mittman · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Ogilvy
Well, you're above Michael Arrington... ;) http://skit.ch/b8hb
· 4 Mart, 06:35

Will Burns · Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Pretty cool, but Facebook is going to have to do a lot to catch up with Disqus. They allow a lot more options for logging in.
1 1 Mart, 09:46

Will Burns · Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
That and I don't want all my web comments popping up on my Facebook profile either.
· 1 Mart, 09:48

Schneider Mike · Boston, Massachusetts
Uh oh... what does this mean for Disqus? Dislike that I can only post to / login on FB. What about Twitter?
1 1 Mart, 09:25

Casey Petersen · University of Arkansas at Monticello
Another big issue - who owns your comments? With disqus, they're synced with comments on the server...in case you decide to move, or do something database related with them (like automatically picking a winner of a prize from comments). It sounds like Facebook will actually own the conversation on your site...
2 1 Mart, 09:40

Simon Cross · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Facebook · 303 abone
TechCrunch can get the comments via an API and store them on their serverside - so essentially, just as before (and like in most commenting platforms) because you're commenting on TechCrunch, TechCrunch can keep your comments.
1 1 Mart, 10:23

Tyson Goodridge · Boston, Massachusetts
Mike- I hear you...feeeling sorry for disqus....- let me know if/when you get alerted to this (says Tyson at 9:43 EST on Tuesday). Will this be "foundable" with search engines?
1 1 Mart, 18:43
Diğer 1

Sean Turvey · New Westminster, British Columbia
I notice it doesn't have live updates of comments or at least something to say "54 new comments".
1 1 Mart, 09:34

Dylan Andersen · Colma, California
Really going to uninspire people to leave comments - even non-troll comments. Sigh.
1 1 Mart, 11:03

Jithin C Nedumala · Make A Difference'de çalışıyor
Facebook's new comment feature is awesome! Google, stop being a spoil sport and let FB in :( Remember: Do no Evil :D
1 1 Mart, 12:01

Jason Wilk · Los Angeles, California
This is great. TechCrunch comments have seriously suffered from anonymity.
1 1 Mart, 12:23

Juan Carlos Muriente · 36 yaşında
Yep
· 1 Mart, 18:56

Fernando Olivares
Click on the ne of the commenter... nothing happens. Click on the avatar of the commenter.. Surprise..
1 1 Mart, 13:47

Courtney Engle · Bloomsburg · 155 abone
I'm still a huge fan of @disqus for the fact they show trackbacks across the web. Twitter integration is useful for me.
1 1 Mart, 16:17

Rhys Bartle · Mahurangi College and Napier Boys High School
This nonsense! Who is going to read 790 comments? Talk about applying a sledgehasmmer to a nut........
1 1 Mart, 16:23

it Lavi · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · it Lavi - Social Media Observer'de Blogger · 123 abone
I don't think trolls will avoid comments just because we can see who they are - we've lost all she haven't we?
1 1 Mart, 23:49

Menny Benady · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · מני בן-עדי SMM שיווק במדיה החברתית'da בעלים
I think the power of self branding (and corporate) will rise... Plus, there will probably be a choice in websites to comment with your FB profile or in the integrated system on the web site ...
· 2 Mart, 00:00

itay Tweeto · Üst Düzey Yorumcu · Freelancer'de Interface Architect (Ux & Ui specialist)
Pretty azing step for Facebook.

(mm...I wonder what this comment will cause on my Facebook page).
1 2 Mart, 00:11

Ad Brwell
Facebook, the herpes of the Internet.

Everybody's got it, and impossible to remove.
1 2 Mart, 03:43

Alexander Rodriguez · Mindclay Creative'de Director of Visual and Interactive
This is a very interesting feature. I'm all for more integration between content sites and social media.
1 2 Mart, 07:40

Steven Lehrburger · New York, New York
Are my Facebook friends necessarily those with whom I want to discuss all of the things I come across online?
1 2 Mart, 17:37

Randolph Novino · Üst Düzey Yorumcu
Wow this is really great feature of the new comment plugins definitely must applied to any website or blog sites.
1 2 Mart, 18:21

Cindy King · Social Media Exiner'de Managing Editor
Really Cool! The updated Facebook comment plugin is definitely worth looking into!
1 2 Mart, 22:02

Linda Coles · Blue Banana'da International speaker, author and consultant
Hey Cindy. A cool feature indeed but with over 1000 comments, I gave up trying to add mine in there. :)
2 2 Mart, 22:20

Paul Simbeck-Hpson · Simbeck Hpson Consultancy'da CEO/Partner
And I was just getting so used to Livefyre... will they be able to integrate this somehow? It's left me with a quandary now!
1 3 Mart, 01:56

Ally VillaDirect · Orlando, Florida
Thanks TC for allowing us to test this new comment change out, this is fantastic! Cant wait to start using it - and using it often!